From what I've seen, the main reasoning that people seem to have for the theory that the Anti-Keno and Anti-Aniken Hate Clubs, is that it says 'Ashley "James" Potter' on the front page, and it also shows his birthday.

I have one question. If you were making a hate club, would you put your details on the main page? No.

You wouldn't want to make it obvious who you were, because then you'd get banned. You wouldn't tell your details to ANYONE.

Having Ashley's details on the main page doesn't prove that it was Ashley. All it proves is that somebody's written down his details somewhere, and then used them in the hate club in order to create the illusion that Ashley's behind it.

The fact is, all they've done is probably show everyone on the site that whoever created the Hate Clubs ISN'T Ashley.

Ashley knows that making Hate Clubs are against the rules, and he's certainly not stupid enough to put his details on the main page if he did. Whoever's trying to get him banned obviously isn't doing a very good job. All people have to do is stop, clear their head and think logically.

Those who still hate him (I won't name names, they know who they are) are, I think, blinded by anger, and just desperate to exact some petty measure of revenge against him. His friends, and most of the smart people on DeviantArt can probably see that this IS NOT Ashley.

Logic.

Gotta love it.